Free Community College, Structured Pathways: Survey of 2-Year-College Leaders

For all the talk about the prospect of free community college, most two-year-college leaders are skeptical about the feasibility that the concept will come to pass in their states.

Even with the federal support that President Obama has proposed as part of the initiative, community college presidents surveyed by Inside Higher Ed remain pessimistic that their state legislatures would support the idea.

The Obama administration's free community college initiative is just one of the issues covered in Inside Higher Ed's first-ever Survey of Community College Presidents, released today in advance of the annual American Association of Community Colleges convention.

The survey, conducted by Gallup Education, sought the impressions of 213 two-year-college leaders on such issues as online instruction and stackable credentials, as well as the serious “skills gap” problems in their respective states and regions. A copy of the report can be downloaded here.

The survey also found that:

• 77 percent of community college presidents believe the skills gap is a serious problem in their local communities, and 89 percent are working with local businesses to close that gap.
• 50 percent of two-year-college presidents agreed that more courses could be moved online without adversely affecting students at their institutions.
• Most two-year leaders don’t view for-profit colleges as a threat, with 62 percent disagreeing that they are losing students to the colleges.
• Only 39 percent of presidents feel their legislatures would back President Obama’s free community college tuition plan even with federal support. That number decreases to 13 percent without federal support.

Community college leaders also don't expect to see much support from the four-year colleges in their state. Ninety-one percent feel their counterparts will be unsupportive of the plan. That squares with the majority of presidents of public master's degree-granting and baccalaureate universities who said they didn't support Obama's proposal in Inside Higher Ed's 2015 Survey of College and University Presidents.

When it comes to the skepticism surrounding free community college tuition, presidents are most likely looking at their current state funding situations, which have seen significant declines, said Steve Katsinas, director of Educational Policy Center at the University of Alabama.

The center found that 31 states had public higher education operating budgets that did not keep up with the Higher Education Price Index for 2014-15 -- that's 17 more states than the previous year, he said.

“Perhaps the presidents are skeptical about the availability of state funding that would be needed for their states to do the required match,” he said.

Structured Pathways

The survey found that 56 percent of two-year-college presidents agreed or strongly agreed that having too many course choices is an obstacle to students' degree completion. Those feelings coincide with 43 percent of presidents agreeing that their colleges are moving toward limiting student choices.

Phillip Neal, the president of Southcentral Kentucky Community and Technical College, said the structured-pathways approach is more focused on developing quality advising relationships between adviser and student than on reducing class choices.

“We adopt the ‘students don’t do optional’ philosophy and require all degree-seeking students to be advised every semester,” Neal said in an email. “During the advising session, the adviser guides the student through choosing an optimal schedule for goal completion.”

Students are registered “on the spot” as soon as they select the schedule, he said.

“This keeps students on target to graduate in the most expeditious time frame,” Neal said. “It also reduces the degree of self-advising, which invariably leads to problems.”

Evelyn Waiwaiole, director at the Center for Community College Student Engagement, points also to Guttman Community College at the City University of New York and Kennedy-King College of Chicago, which have both seen success using guided or structured pathways.