Threads Across Time

Undergraduates need to see the forest, not just the trees.

Given the sharp decline in the quantity and quality of history instruction in K-12 schools, students now more than ever need a big-picture course that examines the cultural developments that have shaped modern societies. These include the growth of individualism, secularization, the rise of scientific rationalism, the development of human rights, the commercialization of culture, globalization and cultural exchange, shifting gender roles, evolving ideas about race, the erosion of social hierarchies and the shift from collective to private identity.

There is a pressing need for an undergraduate course that moves beyond isolated historical events and explores the key themes that have driven long-term cultural change over the past 2,500 years. Such a course would provide students with a framework to understand the shifts in values and ideas that have created the modern world. Students would learn how these themes have evolved over millennia and why they remain relevant today.

More than just learning disconnected facts, students need to grasp the larger patterns that have shaped human history. A course on long-term cultural changes offers this big-picture perspective, allowing students to see how seemingly unrelated events and ideas are connected by broader historical trends. This deeper, more coherent understanding of the past helps students see its relevance to the present and equips them to better navigate the complexities of the modern world.

---

There was a time when big-picture history books by authors like Oswald Spengler, H. G. Wells, Arnold Toynbee, Will Durant and William H. McNeill offered sweeping narratives of human history, tracing the long-term development of key themes that shaped world or Western civilizations. These works aimed to provide broad overviews of human progress, exploring cultural, political and intellectual transformations over centuries.

Oswald Spengler’s The Decline of the West (1918) argued that civilizations follow a life cycle of birth, growth, maturity and decline, akin to living organisms. He viewed Western civilization as being in its final phase, heading toward authoritarianism and a decline in creativity.

H. G. Wells’s The Outline of History (1920) examined the biological and social evolution of humanity, stressing humanity’s common destiny and the role of reason and science in shaping the future. Wells emphasized human progress and the potential for a united world society.

Arnold Toynbee’s A Study of History (1934–1961) analyzed the rise and fall of 21 civilizations, arguing that history follows cyclical patterns of growth, breakdown and disintegration. Toynbee’s thesis was that civilizations succeed when they effectively respond to challenges but decline when their elites become complacent or fail to innovate.

Will and Ariel Durant’s The Story of Civilization (1935–1975), an 11-volume series, covered Western history from antiquity to the Napoleonic era. The Durants focused on the development of human thought, philosophy, art and religion, providing a coherent narrative of Western civilization’s progress through its intellectual and cultural achievements.

Lewis Mumford’s The City in History (1961) examined how urban centers have driven human progress and societal change, shaping social life, culture and political organization while influencing humanity’s relationship with the environment.

Carroll Quigley’s The Evolution of Civilizations (1961) adopted structural-functionalist approach, arguing that changes in social institutions drive historical change and that civilizations go through stages of expansion, crisis and decline.

William H. McNeill’s The Rise of the West (1963) was groundbreaking for its global perspective, emphasizing the interconnectedness of civilizations and the importance of cross-cultural exchange in shaping human history. McNeill argued that the rise of Western Europe was a product of global interactions, not a self-contained phenomenon.

While textbooks on world history or Western civilization remain common, accessible big-picture history books for a broader audience have become much rarer, with notable exceptions, like Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs and Steel (1997) and Yuval Noah Harari’s Sapiens (2011).

Unlike the classic works by Spengler, Toynbee and the Durants, which emphasize philosophical, cultural and moral explanations for the rise and fall of civilizations and present history as a narrative shaped by moral lessons, cycles and human destiny, recent works by Diamond and Harari claim to be more scientific and analytic.

Diamond’s focus on geographical determinism and Harari’s emphasis on evolution, collective myths and cognitive and technological shifts are less concerned with specific cultures or individual societies and more focused on supposedly universal patterns in human development, systems, structures and collective human behavior.

In contrast to the deterministic frameworks of Diamond and Harari, earlier historians viewed history as driven by human agency, moral decisions and religious, philosophical and political ideas. These earlier works were often heavily Eurocentric, portraying the West as the pinnacle of human civilization.

The decline of the Durant-style cultural history is straightforward: Today’s historians see it as too didactic, teleological and linear, tied to grand narratives that are no longer in vogue. As academic history has become more specialized, focusing on narrower subjects, time periods and regions, big-picture histories—requiring broad generalizations—are met with skepticism by scholars who prefer detailed, micro-historical studies. The rise of theoretical approaches such as cultural, social, economic, gender and postcolonial history has shifted attention away from overarching narratives to more localized, specific phenomena.

In addition, public reading habits have shifted toward shorter, more specialized books and articles, with fewer readers seeking out dense, multivolume histories. However, the value of grand narratives remains, offering insights into broader patterns and themes that continue to shape human history.

---

While many historians may hesitate to offer a course on broad, long-term cultural trends due to specialization, fragmentation or concerns about oversimplification, the value of such a course lies in its ability to connect students with the big picture of history. Undergraduates would greatly benefit from a framework that ties together the key historical developments shaping Western societies over time.

In a world where the pace of change can feel overwhelming, a course that traces the long-term cultural developments of the West provides students with the historical context needed to make sense of contemporary innovations and challenges. It helps them understand that modern values—individualism, secularism, human rights and scientific rationalism—are the result of centuries-long processes. By exploring these broad trends, students gain insight into how the past continues to shape the present, equipping them with the intellectual tools to navigate today’s complexities.

With new technologies and societal changes emerging at an unprecedented rate, it’s easy to lose track of the larger historical context. A course on long-term cultural shifts in the West shows that today’s transformations are part of a much longer process. For example, the rise of individualism in the early modern era laid the groundwork for the personal freedoms and self-expression we take for granted in today’s digital age. By studying this progression, students can better understand how contemporary values around autonomy and identity are rooted in centuries of transformation, not created in a vacuum.

Technological innovation is often viewed as the primary driver of societal change, but without understanding the cultural shifts that accompany these advances, their full significance remains elusive. A course on the cultural history of the West broadens students’ perspectives, illustrating how technological, political and social innovations are intertwined with long-standing philosophical and ethical debates. For example, studying the rise of scientific rationalism helps students see that modern technological advances are part of a broader cultural shift toward reason and empirical inquiry.

Similarly, today’s struggles for racial equality, gender rights and social justice can be better understood by tracing their origins through Western history. The modern emphasis on equality and individual dignity is connected to earlier movements like the Enlightenment’s challenge to absolutist power and the expansion of democratic ideals. By placing these modern struggles in their historical context, students gain a deeper appreciation for the continuity of human rights activism and the evolving social values that shape contemporary debates.

Globalization, often seen as a uniquely modern phenomenon, has deep historical roots. A course on Western cultural history reveals that cultural exchange and interaction have been central to Western development for centuries, from the Hellenistic period to the Age of Exploration and European colonialism. Understanding this history helps students contextualize modern issues such as migration, global markets and cross-cultural influence, showing that globalization is a continuation of trends that have long shaped the world.

Shifts in gender roles, ideas about race and the movement from collective to private identity have also profoundly impacted modern society. A big-picture course would explore the historical roots of these transformations, helping students understand how ideas about gender, race and identity have evolved over time. The development of feminist thought in the 19th and 20th centuries, for example, can be linked to earlier debates about women’s roles in society dating back to classical Greece and Rome. Similarly, today’s debates around race can be traced to colonial and imperial practices that shaped Western racial hierarchies. Understanding these historical foundations equips students to critically engage with contemporary social and political issues.

Today’s world faces unprecedented challenges, from climate change and mass migration to the ethical dilemmas posed by emerging technologies. While these problems may seem uniquely modern, many of the cultural and intellectual tools needed to address them have deep historical roots. For instance, debates around artificial intelligence can be enriched by historical discussions about science and the dangers of human overreach, issues that have been debated since the Enlightenment.

A big-picture course emphasizes that cultural shifts over the past 2,500 years have been neither linear nor uniform. Instead, they have unfolded through a complex interplay of continuity and change. For example, while secularization has been a long-term trend in Western history, it has often coexisted with periods of religious revival and renewed interest in spirituality. Studying these patterns allows students to appreciate the complexity of cultural change and avoid simplistic narratives that portray progress as inevitable or assume that modern society represents the culmination of historical development.

In short, a course on long-term cultural developments provides students with the historical framework they need to engage thoughtfully with the present and future.

---

Rather than being organized by chronology, such a course would be thematic, with each module focusing on a long-term trend such as individualism, secularization or globalization.

Each module of the course would focus on a specific theme. Here are some themes that make sense to me.

• Individualism and the inner self: This module traces the evolution from collective identity in classical antiquity to the rise of personal autonomy and introspection during the Renaissance and Enlightenment. The shift toward individuality reflects the increasing focus on personal freedom and self-expression, which continues to shape modern ideas about identity and agency.
• Secularization and religious change: This module explores the gradual shift from a religiously dominated worldview to a secular one, emphasizing key moments such as the Reformation, Enlightenment and modern secular movements. Secularization involves the decline of religious influence over public life, science, politics and morality, with human reason, empirical science and individual rights increasingly taking precedence over religious doctrine.
• The growth of secular morality and ethics: Examining the development of ethical systems independent of religious frameworks, this module would highlight thinkers like Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who articulated moral systems based on reason, human dignity and social welfare. This shift has had a profound impact on contemporary debates surrounding human rights, justice and individual responsibility, with secular ethics now shaping much of our legal, political and social behavior.
• Scientific rationalism: This module focuses on the impact of the Scientific Revolution and its precursors and the growing emphasis on empirical inquiry, which replaced mythological and religious explanations of natural phenomena. Scientific rationalism reshaped how we understand the world and contributed to the technological advances that continue to transform society today.
• Human rights and social justice: Exploring the historical development of various kinds of rights—natural rights, status-based rights, legal claims and immunities, civil rights and human rights—this module looks at major reforms, such as the abolition of slavery, women’s suffrage and the civil rights movements. Western societies have increasingly embraced the idea that individuals have inherent rights and that governments should be accountable to the people. This trend has led to significant political and social reforms that continue to shape contemporary struggles for equality.
• The rise of consumerism: Of all the -isms that have shaped Western values—including communism, conservatism, fascism and liberalism—perhaps the most powerful has been consumerism, with material wealth and the acquisition of goods often equated with success and happiness. This module explores how consumer culture has shaped identity and desire, while also raising ethical concerns about sustainability, environmental degradation and the implications of consumption-driven economies.
• The commercialization and commodification of culture: From the rise of urban centers and trade to the Industrial Revolution, cultural production—whether in art, literature or music—has become increasingly tied to economic forces. This module examines the tension between commercial success and artistic integrity, showing how consumer culture and advertising have influenced cultural expression and identity formation.
• Globalization and cultural exchange: This module examines the historical roots of globalization, from colonialism to modern economic interdependence and its impact on culture, language and identity. Globalization has led to the blending of cultures, creating hybrid forms of art, music and political thought. However, it has also sparked tensions around cultural identity, nationalism and multiculturalism.
• The shift from collective to private identity: The emphasis on collective identity, where one’s identity was largely defined by class, family or religious community, has gradually shifted to a focus on personal identity. This module explores how individualism and personal expression have influenced modern understandings of gender, sexuality and personal freedom, encouraging people to define themselves independently of societal norms.
• Gender and sexuality: Analyzing the historical development of gender roles and family structures, this module examines how feminist movements in the 19th and 20th centuries challenged traditional gender roles, leading to significant legal, social and cultural reforms. The ongoing evolution of gender roles continues to influence contemporary discussions about identity, power and equity.
• Race and the transformation of social hierarchies: This module explores the historical construction of race and its impact on social hierarchies, as well as the ongoing struggle for racial equality. Movements for civil rights and social justice have challenged and eroded rigid social hierarchies based on birth, class and race. This theme emphasizes how democratic values and meritocracy have transformed Western societies, even as inequality persists.

Each of these themes provides students with a deeper understanding of the long-term forces that have shaped Western culture, offering a more cohesive framework for analyzing how the past continues to influence the present.

---

In an era of rapid change and overwhelming access to information, students need more than a piecemeal understanding of historical events. They must be equipped with the tools to discern the larger patterns and long-term developments that have shaped the trajectory of Western societies. By focusing on the growth of individualism, secularization, human rights, scientific rationalism, globalization and other key cultural shifts, a course on long-term cultural developments offer students a framework for interpreting not only the past but also the present and future.

Such a course fosters a deeper, more holistic understanding of the forces that continue to shape our world, encouraging students to think critically, make informed connections and approach modern challenges with a sense of historical perspective.

Ultimately, by embracing the broad view of history, we empower students to see the complexity of human experience—giving them the tools to navigate an increasingly interconnected and rapidly evolving global society with insight, depth and purpose.