Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

Quick Takes: How Attitudes Derail Math, College Funds Found to Have Been Misused, Mergers in Georgia, Why a Provost Left After 7 Weeks, Threats Shut Middle Tennessee, Turkey Turmoil at Harvard B-School

  • Cultural attitudes in the United States discourage the most talented students in mathematics — especially female students — from advancing in the field, according to a study that will appear today in the Notices of the American Mathematical Society. Unlike many previous studies that have focused on the poor performance of American students overall, this report examined participants in top mathematics competitions for students. “The U.S. culture that is discouraging girls is also discouraging boys,” says Janet Mertz, a professor of oncology at the University of Wisconsin at Madison and the senior author of the study. “The situation is becoming urgent. The data show that a majority of the top young mathematicians in this country were not born here.” One bit of evidence cited in the report: Eighty percent of female and 60 percent of male faculty members hired in recent years by the very top research university mathematics departments in the United States were born in other countries.
  • A law firm hired by the City College of San Francisco has found that the college, at the direction of the then-chancellor, Philip Day, steered more than $28,000 in public funds into campaigns for two education measures before voters in 2006, The San Francisco Chronicle reported. According to the newspaper, such use of public funds appears to violate state laws. Day has since moved on to lead the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators. He told the paper that its report was “not true.”
  • Georgia’s technical college system plans to merge 14 of its 33 institutions, so that 7 presidents’ positions and some other senior jobs can be eliminated to save money, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported. State officials said the cuts would save money without eliminating course offerings. But some local officials in communities whose local college would be subsumed into another fear a loss of clout for their hometown campuses.
  • Rumors have been flying at Washington State University since Provost Steven Hoch went on leave abruptly, only seven weeks into the job and without any public explanation from the university. The Seattle Times is today reporting that Hoch left after clashing with vice presidents who did not share his view that they should report to him, and that a heated meeting ended with Hoch and Greg Royer, the vice president for business and finance, in a corridor in which one man apparently tried to push the other. Neither man commented for the article, but the incident is the subject of an internal review, the Times said.
  • Citing a “credible threat,” Middle Tennessee State University shut down Thursday and will not hold scheduled classes Friday. While officials did not reveal details about the threat, a statement said that the decision followed “a series of threatening e-mails and suspicious fires.” The Associated Press reported that police arrested a 19-year old student on terrorism charges, but authorities have not revealed a motive.
  • A turkey, uninvited, has made a home at the campus of Harvard Business School, and some students are demanding that the turkey pay a price for allegedly chasing them and for scratching cars. But The Boston Globe reported that university officials say that they are barred from moving the turkey. “The turkey is considered protected wildlife, and in Massachusetts, it’s against the law to relocate wildlife,” said one administrator. “So until then, all we can do really is let the turkey be and monitor reports about how aggressive it is.”

Scott Jaschik

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Turkey at Harvard Biz School

I’m surprised that Harvard didn’t offer the turkey a professorship on the tenured track. Or if it’s degree credentials were a bit hazy, a full scholarship in the name of cultural diversity.

rosanne soifer, adjunct—Music Business and Lifeskills at Touro College-NYC, at 8:40 am EDT on October 10, 2008

Turkey on the green

Just wait for hunting season, get a permit, and shoot the critter. Then serve turkey and noodles in the cafeteria. (Of course you’d probably need another special permit to carry and discharge a firearm on the campus or in the city...) Oh no, wait. Massachusetts is a liberal state so they probably don’t have any control of guns there.

Turkey-Lurkey, at 8:40 am EDT on October 10, 2008

Turkey

You call this news? There have been turkeys on college campuses for years.

Cranberry Sauce, at 8:40 am EDT on October 10, 2008

“The U.S. culture that is discouraging girls is also discouraging boys,”

Discouraging girls? What planet are these authors on? We have had decades of encouragement of girls in education, including math, while boys languish. In fact the press release linked above has the heading “US culture derails girl math whizzes", no mention of those boys. ‘U.S. culture that is encouraging girls is discouraging boys’ would be more like it.

Beam Me Up, at 9:25 am EDT on October 10, 2008

Derailed Math

In southern Illinois in 1967, I was the only girl at my huge consolidated high school EVER to have taken physics. When I walked into the physics lab, the teacher told me I was in the wrong place, and sent me back to the office to check. An administrator had to accompany me to the classroom and order the teacher to admit me.

The teacher retaliated by seating me far back in the lab, with six empty rows between me and the male students. Of course, I did poorly in the course. I could barely see the board or hear the instructor’s voice!

I recall, in the late 1980’s, reading an article in the New York Times detailing physical differences between male and female brains as the cause of the supposedly natural differences between males and females in mathematical and mechanical ability.

Then I came to teach in the Middle East, where I was astonished to discover that, in both secondary and postsecondary school, girls take exactly the same mathematics and physical science courses as boys do, and do better, on the average, than boys do in these subjects.

There are physical differences between male and female brains, but to assume that these differences are the cause of American women’s underachievement in mathematics is like saying that children who don’t have the opportunity to go to school can’t read because they are less intelligent that those who do.

Anne Osman, at 9:51 am EDT on October 10, 2008

Derailed in Math

I have observed that primary school education in math is so poor that many students succeed despite the educational system rather than because of it.

In addition, the American obsession with getting rich steers students who are proficient in math toward finance and Wall Street rather than engineering, math science and academics.

Miles D. Berkow, at 12:05 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

Derailed Math

Let’s see — first, the calculator industry told us that the earlier one uses a calculator in life, the mind would become “free” to teach itself.

Math Ed majors learn a lot less math, and from fewer actual mathematicians, than do professional math majors.

Many elementary and middle school teachers did not have to take much math. In fact, many cannot teach math, much less without a calculator.

Even the president of my college informs incoming students that algebra was “to hard” for him to understand.

What do we expect? When we don’t raise the bar, students will rarely achieve the appropriate goal on their own.

Things will get much worse before they ever get better. I hope to live long enough to teach a math class whose collective knowledge of math equals the entire collective knowledge of my classmates in high school.

Mathematician, at 2:50 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

math for girls

Mathematician, The entirety of your post is self-serving. You spend it all bragging about how much you know about math. I don’t think I should take your word for it.

Yes, “Math Ed” is a joke major. But that doesn’t explain or refute the argument that girls are being discouraged.

Ms. Osman, The country has changed a lot since the 1960s. Despite your righteous indignation about an article from the 1960s, you didn’t say whether or not it is true that lady brains are different than man brains, and if, so, whether those differences make it hard to learn math.

However, in my experience I have seen nothing about encouragement for any young lady that wants to study math. Unfortunately, too many young ladies opt to attend parties or watch TV, so they won’t be good at anything.

Larry, at 4:30 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

Mergers in Georgia Just a Start

The merger in Georgia is likely just the first wave in response to the economic depression hitting the world. It is also very likely that the HED for the next year will have a longer than usual of college closings too. And not just for-profit career colleges either. There are many small privates and even not-for-profits that are teetering on the edge. The pool of potential students will shrink as jobs are lost. College tuition loans will tighten making the pool even shallower. Public support and donations will dry up.

Yet, we will not learn. Likely raise tuition and cut out more students. We will still focus on admissions when retention is going to be the key. And we probably will not change with the reality of our economic and social situation which will lose us more support. (http://academicmaps.blogspot.com/...s-lose-billions-of-dollars-and.html)

We should change ourselves before others change us! Georgia, I fear is just the start.Neal R www.academicmaps.blogspot.com

Neal Raisman, President at Academicmaps, at 6:00 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

To Larry:

Yes, girls were being discouraged. But now everyone is.

I have re-read my comment and I can only wonder about why you took it that way.

The facts are facts. Deal with it. And while you’re at it, put down your calculator.

Math Guy, at 6:00 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

“I have seen nothing about encouragement"?

Give me a break. There is nothing but encouragement for girls now.

DFS, at 6:00 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

Math and Girls

There was knowledge out there which is being no longer conveyed.

The calculators have deleted this. This will become apparent over time. I send you to Well’s College Algebra, 1904.

Another Mathematician, at 6:00 pm EDT on October 10, 2008

Turkey

Has anyone examined the pedigree of the turkey? Is there a possibility that the turkey is simply a “lost” President?

Linda Bourgeois, Ph.D., Director, Campus Diversity at MVSU, at 12:30 pm EDT on October 12, 2008

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to Quick Takes: How Attitudes Derail Math, College Funds Found to Have Been Misused, Mergers in Georgia, Why a Provost Left After 7 Weeks, Threats Shut Middle Tennessee, Turkey Turmoil at Harvard B-School

or search for jobs directly.

Assistant Professor of Spanish/Medieval
Miami University

Assistant Professor of Spanish, tenure-track, to begin August, 2009. Ph. D. in hand by August 17, 2009. The Department of ... see job

Social Work Program — Internship Supervisors/Instructors
Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania

Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania invites applications for two Internship Supervisors see job

Assistant Professor/Associate Professor
Western Carolina University

Assistant or Associate Professor of Organizational Communication. The Department of Communication at Western Carolina ... see job

Microbiology Adjunct Faculty Pool
Howard Community College

HCC offers two courses related to Microbiology: * Fundamentals of Microbiology is a course designed with a strong emphasis ... see job

Tenure-Track, Assistant Professor in 18th-Century French Literature and Culture
University of Colorado

Posting Description: The French and Italian Department at the University of Colorado, Boulder is seeking ... see job

Faculty, Life/Health Sciences
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Scientist
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

572 Accountancy
California State University, Long Beach

California State University, Long Beach College of Business Administration Department of Accountancy Tenure-Track Faculty ... see job

Accountant II
Community College of Baltimore County

Job Responsibilities: Under the supervision of the Capital Finance Manager, the Sr. Accountant Specialist I ... see job

School of Mathematics Position; Tenured
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job