Advertisement

Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

A New Tack for the DREAM Act

An amendment that would attach the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act to the Department of Defense authorization bill never made it to the Senate floor Wednesday after Democratic leaders, unsuccessful in their bid to compel a withdrawal of troops from Iraq, shifted gears to focus on student loan legislation. Still, the attempt to connect a critical defense bill with the DREAM Act — which would, among other things, provide a pathway to permanent residency for undocumented immigrants who undertake at least two years of college or military service – may represent a shift in strategy for advocates who have watched the bill long languish amidst contentious and inconclusive immigration reform battles.

U.S. Senators Richard Durbin (D-Ill.), Chuck Hagel (R-Neb.) and Richard Lugar (R-Ind.) were expected to introduce an amendment encompassing the DREAM Act during the debate of the defense authorization bill that was cut short Wednesday. Sandra Abrevaya, a spokeswoman for Senator Durbin, said Wednesday afternoon that the majority whip will still be looking to introduce the amendment whenever the Senate next returns its attention to the defense authorization bill, and added that, should this approach ultimately fail, “He’ll look at the very next opportunity.”

In addition to offering the permanent residency pathway to illegal immigrants who entered the country before age 16, the amendment also would clarify these students’ eligibility for in-state tuition (a murky and much-debated issue at present) and, for the first time, render them eligible for federal student loans and work study. Although the original DREAM Act was first proposed in Congress in 2001, and was included in the Senate’s unsuccessful stab at comprehensive immigration reform this spring, the full House and Senate chambers have yet to take a vote on the act as a stand-alone measure.

“I think we have a shot at passage; we’re expecting that it will need 60 votes to prevail because most of the amendments that have come up have faced a filibuster,” said Jim Hermes, senior legislative associate for the American Association of Community Colleges, one of 11 higher education associations that registered support for the DREAM Act in a Tuesday letter from David Ward, president of the American Council on Education.

“Obviously this is something that is connected to the overall issue of immigration reform, but this particular issue in terms of expanding the opportunity to people who were brought here as kids we think is 1) a less controversial issue and 2) one that speaks to basic issues of fairness and justice,” Hermes said.

The measure, though less controversial than other immigration reform proposals, is still likely to face some significant opposition from lawmakers who don’t want to reward illegal entry into the United States. “My heart goes out to all those who aren’t in control of their destiny ... but by the same token, the United States needs to be in control of its own destiny,” Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) said during a Congressional hearing on undocumented student issues in May.

Despite the impasse over Iraq that forced the bill off the floor Wednesday, the authorization act, in some form, is “a must-pass bill,” Hermes pointed out. “At some point, they’ll have to come back to it.”

“There are a lot of questions on the broader-based [defense authorization] bill,” said Melissa Lazarin, associate director for education policy for the National Council of La Raza. “We’re hopeful that we will have an opportunity to debate this amendment. But if this vehicle does not work out, we will be identifying other vehicles to pass this.”

Elizabeth Redden

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Make DREAM a reality

With the increadible drop-out rate in many immigrant communities, it’s an incredible accomplishment that these students make it to college at all. Many of these students face social, financial, cutltural, and personal obstacles that would normally make achieveing higher education impossible. There has been improvement with the introduction of in-state tuition bills in various states. But that only goes part of the way. These students need access to financial aid and student support programs. Undocumented college students face such an uncertain future, yet they have this immense faith in the United States. Even those undocumented soldiers serving in the military believe that the United States will take care of them. These people have already made positive contributions to the United States. The schools are still receiving funding based on student enrollment. The military gets to meet quota numbers based on recruitment of undocumented enlistees. These undocumented people are for all intentional puposes upstanding citizens. Yet these people are not full players in the system, at no fault of their own. It’s not as if serving in the military or completing two years of college is some big “loop hole” to US citizenship. Just look at the statistics. The average US citizen, cannot/would not be able to say they meet those requirements. For the revitalization of an aging(babyboomer)population and for national security, the DREAM Act must become a reality.

Lily E. Espinoza, Director, EOPS at CA Community College, at 1:45 pm EDT on July 19, 2007

DREAM ACT

I’ll support the DREAM Act the day it includes the requirements that the parents or relatives who brought these children here are NOT ELIGIBLE to be sponsored for legal status by them, or better yet, that they will be required to leave the U.S. before the children can get legal status. After all, a main objection to the DREAM Act is that it rewards the adults who brought these kids here for their illegal acts.

Ali, at 2:25 pm EDT on July 19, 2007

Dream On

The bottom line — illegal is illegal. We need to be taking care of our own American citizens and legal immigrants — not caring for those who flagrantly break the laws of this country. Period.

NoVA mom, at 2:30 pm EDT on July 19, 2007

Outrageousness of University Liberals

Of course the whole thing is outrageous. It takes away scarce resources from American citizens children and other Americans. It is an abomination—nothing less.

Bobby, at 5:00 pm EDT on July 19, 2007

Some of these students are obviously the best and the brightest to have gotten as far as college and in some cases enrolled in advanced degree programs. It would be short-sighted and just stupid to educate these kids and not let them become assets to this country. Don’t let them take their education to another country, we need them here! The DREAM act sounds fair and just. p.s. lord knows we need them in the military, another job our"citizens” don’t want to do.

frances, at 6:55 pm EDT on July 19, 2007

DREAM Act

First, it should be remembered that this is not a give-away program; no one is talking about a free education for these undocumented college students; it not about scarce resources or denying Americans an equal opportunity. Second, and I say this as an adjunct faculty member at a community college: I have personally found that immigrants — lawful or otherwise — are excellent students. Tragically, they seem far more mature and dedicated to bettering themselves, and show greater respect for education, than most of the Americans I teach, especially the younger ones just out of high school. It breaks my heart to say this, but at least 40% of the high school graduates I teach are dumb as a box of hammers — and they are usually U.S. citizens, white, and middle class. It is a national scandal.

Micky, at 6:05 am EDT on July 20, 2007

DREAM SHOULD PASS!

THE DREAM ACT WILL ONLY BE ELIGIBLE FOR THOSE STUDENTS WHO HAVE GOOD MORALS AND CONDUCT. THOSE CHILDREN WHO WOULD BENEFIT FROM THE DREAM ACT DID NOT MAKE THE CHOICE OF COMING TO THIS COUNTRY WHEN THEY WERE YOUNG. MOST STUDENTS WHO WOULD BENEFIT FROM THE DREAM ACT BECAUSE THEY WOULD BE ABLE TO USE THEIR TALENTS. ONLY STUDENTS WHO GO TO HIGHER EDUCATION OR THOSE WHO WISH TO SERVE N THE MILITARY WOULD BENEFIT. I SUPPORT THIS BILL 100%!

JESSICA, at 6:05 am EDT on July 20, 2007

Dream Act

The Dream Act is a fair and just way to accept those kids who call America their home and have literally grown up here. They are America and that is all that they have known. America needs to accept these children at some point or the other and needs to realize that they are an asset, because like it or not they are citizens os this country in theri heart. Use the talent and resources that exists within our borders and make this country stronger. No one can even come close to identifying what these students go thorough on a daily basis in terms of knowing that they cannot reach their dreams and goals because of something that they did not have any control over. Imagine being able to eat and not taste, imagine being able to hear and not see. America needs to become a loving stepmother and accept what awaits on her door step.

SK, at 6:05 am EDT on July 20, 2007

I think most U.S. citizens would agree with awarding citizenship to illegals willing to serve in our military, however, to allow illegals the right to compete for the limited number of federal or state grants with our own hard working and poverty stricken youth, who have also defied the odds and “dream” of a better life, is unfair and undermines their efforts.

Wouldn’t it better serve all involved if those lobbying for amnesty for “all” illegal aliens, would concentrate only on the good students and those wishing to serve in our military, who are the only “real” assets to our society? The majority of U.S. citizens will never agree to any form of amnesty for people who have willfully violated our immigration laws, but many have no objection to allowing a path to citizenship to children who were brought into this country at a young age and strived to do well in school, WITHOUT giving them an opportunity to later sponser their parents for legalization or citizenship. The millions/billions spent lobbying Congress would be much better spent on scholarships for these kids, than wasted on cheap labor and criminal aliens.

Annette, at 6:05 am EDT on July 20, 2007

Concerning the quote you made below:

“It breaks my heart to say this, but at least 40% of the high school graduates I teach are dumb as a box of hammers.”

If our American children are dumb as a box of hammers, then that means you are not a very good teacher and did not do your job well. Why would we want to take college slots away from our american children and educate illegal alien children.

I belive you are dumb as a box of hammers.

Vanity, at 11:00 am EDT on July 20, 2007

I’m Personally Disgusted with NY State

My state, NY State, provides illegal immigrants with in-state tuition breaks of in-state residents.

I didn’t vote for this, and if there was some way to penalize former NY Governor George Pataki for this, I would.

Jon S, I’m Personally Disgusted with NY, at 6:20 pm EDT on July 20, 2007

I would support the Dream Act if US citizens and legal immigrants that want to go to college were given the same and every opportunity to further their college education. If this government can waive the in-state tuition for the undocumented, it can surely waive the in-state tuition for its own youth. Till then I will continue to contact DC to vote the Dream Act down.

Cathreina, at 7:55 pm EDT on July 20, 2007

I support DERAM ACT!

Our government has spent billions of dollars on these kids who brought to this country illegally. These kids are our assets and they will payback their dues by giving them this opportunity to finish their education in college and work for this country or let them to serve in our military. Those students who worked hard and stayed out of any trouble deserve a chance to become part of our society. If these kids barred from any higher education or from an active and productive job, then we are going to have a massive social unrest. The reality is that they are not going anywhere regardless of this ACT! America is the only place they know and lived. WE HAVE TO ACCEPT THIS FACT....

Michelle, at 5:55 am EDT on July 21, 2007

Our government is already giving undocumented students K-12 education, so it makes sense to offer them a chance for higher education as well. If we don’t, our economy and nation as a whole suffers. Besdies these children were brought here not by their own will, some were brought here at one or two years old and do not even speak their native language, it makes sense to let them stay and contribute to the society where they grew up.

Sam, at 5:45 pm EDT on July 21, 2007

Dream Act

BY passing the Dream act my dreams and the dreams of thousands of other illegal students can become true. it is difficult for us not to have the same rights as other students, even if we have a high average, we still dont qualify for many programs offered by intitutions. I came to this country when I was 15, we came legally, with a tourist’s visa. My father had to get us out of my country (Colombia) due to the extreme violence of that time. violence that is still happening at this present day. we left everything behind. two months after being here I enrolled in high school. it was a great experience because it was a totally new world for me. new language, new culture, new weather. everything.after I graduated, I was afraid to go to college because of my situation in the country. but anyway I did, working two jobs I saved some money to pay for tuition. at this moment I graduated from a two year college and im ready to continue my education at a senior college. but the situation without paper sometimes destroys my enthusiasm to continue. what will I do with a bachelors degree if I cant get a decent job without a work permit? even with my associate degree, the doors close for me. its like a dead end.

at this moment im very much hoping that the government of the United States will pass the DREAM ACT. we as students can offer a lot to this country if given the opportunity.

David Diaz, current student at BMCC (borough of manhattan Community College), at 9:05 pm EDT on July 24, 2007

I did some research which made up my mind about this bill. According to Thomas LOC, the people benefiting fromt the DREAM Act would not be elegible to obtain state or fed grants. I support the DREAM Act.

Chris, Just some info, at 12:55 pm EDT on July 26, 2007

Dream Act

All of you who are against the DREAM Act has no sense of human decency whatsoever. Imagine, being punished for 20years for some thing that your parent did. If you can exercise some critical thinking, then you would understand that this country was NOT built on the sins of the father visiting the other generation. Those students who stay in school and do the right thing should be awarded their legal status. Their is fair and humane thing to do.

Margaret, at 12:30 pm EDT on July 27, 2007

DREAM Act

I am really tired of hearing the term “rewarding illegal behavior” when we talk about any type of comprehensive immigration reform. Is making the beds in your hotel rooms, preparing and serving your food and washing the dishes in the restaurant you eat in, and picking your vegetables illegal behavior? And we all reap the benefits of the hard work of undocumented immigrants, yet some want to simultaneously yell about how bad they are.The students who will be helped by the DREAM Act will be the future educated workforce that this country needs. They want to stay in this country and contribute. Those of you who decry “illegal aliens” don’t mind that they are cooking the food in your favorite restaurant, but you don’t want them to have the chance to become educated, legal members of our country.

Jeanne, at 5:25 am EDT on August 2, 2007

DREAM ACT

Today is my first day of Law School!! This is a big achievement for me and my family, however, being undocumented for the last 17 years has made it difficult to come this far. I love this country because this is the only home I know. The DREAM Act will make my dream of becoming a Civil Rights Lawyer a reality.

Luis, Law Student at California, at 5:50 am EDT on August 3, 2007

DREAM ACT

Just to reiterate: the DREAM Act does not secure federal or state grants for students. It simply allows students whow meet qualifications to pay in state tuition but are not here legally, to pay the state tuition, and then gives them the cance to work towards legal status upon graduating or serving in the millitary. Several posts state that the reason for being against the DREAM act is that it takes funds away from citizens. If that is the only basis for you to be against the act, then you need to read more carefully, do a little a research, and support the DREAM Act!

Amy, Student, at 1:20 pm EDT on August 4, 2007

pass the dream act

Dream Act is a great oportunnity for those kids who want to join in the military. Im one of them!!!!!!!!!

luis garcia, pass the dream act, at 5:35 am EDT on September 2, 2007

How to Support the DREAM Act

It is important that we give these responsible students, who are trying to make better lives for themselves, the opportunities that the DREAM Act will provide. To support the DREAM Act please sign these petitions:

http://www.petitiononline.com/dre...etitiononline.com/da07/petition.html

It is also important to call the senators to show support. You can find all of their numbers at the following links. Senators only: http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm Senators and House Representatives:http://www.conservativeusa.org/mega-cong.htm

Please tell everyone you know to show support by calling and signing. It is imperative that we not only post comments on the internet but also tell the senators how we feel!

Thank you,Kjersti

Kjersti, Student, at 5:50 pm EDT on September 20, 2007

I don’t understand why people are referring to this piece of legislation as a hand out or as a reward for illegal behavior. Together with my family, I came to this country when I was twelve from the country of Colombia-no choice of mine. I graduated from High School with honors and a number of scholarships which I couldn’t accept because of my status of residency.With no papers, but plenty of enthusiasm I’ve worked and continue to work all different types of odd jobs so I could enrolled at one of U-Mass’s schools of Engineering. Im still there and almost done, whats to be of me a year from now?..five years from now?...thats a very good question which I always struggle in answering when asked by my professors and peers...????Even though I wouldn’t have to because of bachelors, if the Dream act goes through I wouldn’t object to serving in the military while striving forth with my desire to go to Law School and focus in patent law.

The Dream Act is not a hand out, its a chance at opportunity!

Alejandro, Engineering Student at University of Mass, at 2:00 pm EDT on September 21, 2007

As an undocumented immigrant I want to thank those U.S. citizents/legal residents who support the Dream Act. I am glad to know that there are compassionate people out there who care not just for their own people but for others as well. I have heard many negative comments from other people and am glad that there’s people like you. Thank you very much for the support and hopefully that Dream will become a reality.

Lucette, at 5:35 pm EDT on October 2, 2007

Thanks and God Bless

I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU ALL FOR THE SUPPORT OF THE DREAM ACT. IT IS A FAIR AND HUMANE THING TO DO. WE CAN DEBATE AGAINST THOSE WHO OPPOSE US BUT IN THE END JUSTICE PREVAILS OVER GREED AND EVIL. I UNLIKE SOME PEOPLE HOLD STRONG TO MY FAITH AND THAT IS WHAT DRIVES ME TO CONTINUE IN HOPES FOR A BETTER FUTURE WITHOUT BARRIERS OR BETTER SAID BORDERS!!~!

SUPPORT THE DREAM ACT!! AND LETS NOT LOOK DOWN TO OUR OPPOSERS. THEY WILL SOON SEE THE LIGHT. ACHIEVERS WILL ALWAYS BE HATED ON AND MANY WILL TRY HARD TO PUT THEM DOWN, BUT ITS OUR STRENGTH WE HAVE INSIDE THAT WILL KEEP THEM OFF OF US!!! GOD BLESS THE WORLD AND KEEP IT EQUAL AND FOR ALL OF US TO SHARE ITS FRUIT!

LES, at 3:00 pm EDT on October 16, 2007

AMERICA’S KIDS FIRST! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

I am a college student, and a non-traditional one at that. It is amazing that I have made it back to college after dropping out of highschool. I now have a 3.6 gpa. unfortunately, school is extremely costly. I made about 15k last year and was only given a $400.00 grant. Yeah, the only reason i even made that much money was because i re-located back to the state of my birth: Illinois. I had to work since i had to delay going back to school. I had to wait to re-establish residency before i could continue my education otherwise I would have had to pay OUT OF STATE TUITION IN THE VERY STATE THAT I WAS BORN IN! IT"S NOT MY FAULT THAT MY FAMILY HAD TO RE-LOCATE BACK TO ILLINOIS!! YET I DON"T GET “special treatment.”

This bill outraged me to NO END. as a college student that works two jobs, drives an hour to and from school, yet still manages to have an exemplary gpa i take umbrage at the idea that i would get even LESS student aid then I GETTING NOW! I WAS BORN IN THIS STATE, GOT A DIPLOMA IN THIS STATE!

When the government proposes extending rights and/or privleges to non-citizens that are above and beyond the rights of citizens then the federal gov is actually making NOTHING OUR CITIZENSHIP!

SHAME ON YOU! YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO REPRESENT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE NOT THE CITIZENS OF MEXICO!

Lar

lara, ms, at 3:40 am EST on December 5, 2007

It’s got my vote because,

These illegal “aliens” that we speak of are human beings. Some have families of their own, and can not provide for them. Yes they can go to school. Thank God that the schools have helped in making it affordable. But what good is going to school if you can’t wok? These senators trying to stop the act from being passed are no better than slave owners. They are cold hearted oppressors.

sarah, sarah, at 8:40 pm EST on December 19, 2007

make the DREAM ACT Happen!!

Here is the thing you American people are soo selfish by not seeing that WE are contributing more than you gusys yeah!! who are the ones who take the jobs you don’t want WE DO!!! if it weren’t for immigrants this country will go Down! I think we deserve an opportunity to get higher education! there are so many American kids who don’t really care about anything but just to want to have fun and they waste their time and money that other kids deserve!!! that is not Fair!!!WE DESERVE AN OPPORTUNITY!!!!

vanessa, at 7:30 pm EDT on April 14, 2008

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to A New Tack for the DREAM Act

or search for jobs directly.

Research Study Coordinator
University of Colorado at Denver and Health Sciences Center-Downtown Denver

Posting Description: The University of Colorado Denver Center for AIDS Research seeks a Part-time ... see job

PRA — Cord Blood Bank
University of Colorado at Denver and Health Sciences Center-Ninth and Colorado

Posting Description: NATURE OF WORK This is a full time (100%FTE) Professional Research Assistant position ... see job

Instructor
Medical University of South Carolina

In the historic, coastal city of Charleston, the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) offers a wide range of ... see job

Department Chair-Biological Sciences
Eastern Illinois University

Eastern Illinois University has a 113 year legacy as an intellectual focal point in central Illinois. Its acclaimed programs ... see job

Development Associate
Weill Medical College of Cornell University

Founded in 1898, and affiliated with what is now New York-Presbyterian Hospital since 1927, Weill Cornell Medical College ... see job

2008/09 Lecturer/Teaching Specialist — Creative Writing
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Assistant Professor (Tenure-Track) Positions in Integrative Physiology
University of Colorado

Posting Description: Specialization- Two positions are available for candidates with expertise in one of the ... see job

Associate Professor — Drug/Device Combinations (Tenured)
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities

The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job

Full-Time Faculty — Fall 2009
College of DuPage

We have some excellent career opportunities for you to lead our students, our organization and our community into a future of ... see job

Economics Instructor
Foothill-DeAnza Community College District

The Foothill-De Anza Community College District is currently accepting applications for the faculty position of Economics ... see job