Advertisement

News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education

‘First Step’ on Simplifying Aid Form

You know that an issue has started to resonate and find its political legs when the relevant players start competing to show they care about it.

One day after lawmakers in both houses of Congress introduced legislation that would cut the length of the Free Application for Federal Student Aid by more than half and take a variety of other steps aimed at making it easier for families to apply for federal aid, the U.S. Education Department unveiled its own effort to give students estimates of their federal financial aid awards earlier in high school and a shortcut to filing the federal financial aid form.

The department’s FAFSA4caster, which will be available publicly April 1 (save the April’s Fool jokes, please), will allow would-be college students or their parents to enter financial information into a tool on the department’s Web site that will then give them an estimate of the federal financial aid they would qualify for and of the “expected family contribution” they should plan to make to pay for college. The information would be stored so that when they are ready to actually apply for aid, it would flow into the FAFSA form, answering about half the questions and saving them time.

By this fall, the forecaster, which is also available in Spanish, will be fleshed out (through partnerships with colleges) to give students “case examples” of how their entire financial aid packages (including state and institutional aid) might look at different types of institutions.

The tool, Education Secretary Margaret Spellings said in a telephone news conference Wednesday, “will help families and students plan for postsecondary education,” and to do so “much earlier than their senior year,” when most students find out how much financial aid they’re eligible for. Spellings called the tool an “important first step” in simplifying the process by which millions of Americans qualify for federal student aid.

That subject has drawn increasing attention of late, as policy makers and advocates for students have looked for explanations for the comparatively low college-going rates of Americans from low-income backgrounds, as well as possible solutions. The complexity of the eight-page (including instructions), 101-question form is oft-cited as a deterrent, both because it seeks a significant amount of financial information that is both difficult to compile and intimidating. A study last year by the American Council on Education estimated that 1.5 million aid-eligible students did not fill out the FAFSA form, and the Secretary of Education’s Commission on the Future of Higher Education decried what Spellings on Wednesday called the “crying need” to make it easier to apply for financial aid.

“Any new federal financial aid system should aim to replace the current federal aid form ... with a much shorter and simpler application form. The application process should be substantially streamlined by analyzing student need through a simple criterion such as family income,” the commission said in its report. “Students should have information about financial aid eligibility (such as need or ability to pay) sooner and with early estimates of likely aid available as soon as the eighth grade.” (Department officials also said they were testing in a small way a method for allowing students who did not have access to a computer to submit their financial information over the phone, so they could benefit from the same early warning system the department plans to provide through the Web-based FAFSA4caster.)

The initiative that Spellings announced Wednesday is just a baby step on the way to that much broader vision, but it is the most concrete step that the department has taken in that direction. It also portends a competition of sorts, coming as it does on the heels of the introduction in the House and Senate Tuesday of legislation that would go significantly further: cutting the form’s length from five pages to two, increasing Web access, allowing high school juniors to file a “Pre-FAFSA” for planning purposes and permitting the sharing of tax information between the Internal Revenue Service and the Department of Education. The last proposal seizes on a report, also issued Tuesday, in which the Institute for College Access and Success calls for enabling students to easily authorize the IRS to forward to the Education Department information about their income and assets that they have submitted on their tax forms.

Spellings acknowledged that that idea and others for going beyond the “first step” the department announced Wednesday were under discussion by department officials, and will be shared and reviewed Thursday during the summit the secretary is holding on carrying out the recommendations of her commission.

Doug Lederman

Got something to say?


Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.

Advertisement

Comments

Fafsa Simplification

The simplest fafsa is one that most prospective students would NOT have to fill out.

Instead, for the vast majority of students a checkoff on whichever version of the 1040 form they file that asks “Would you like the IRS to share your data with the Department of Education for purposes of applying for Federal Student Financial Aid for college". The fact that the tax filer initiates the action fulfills any concerns about needing signatures for permission to disclose the data. After all the question is at least as important as “would you like to contribute $3 towards the presidential election fund".

The IRS can transmit the data electronically. The 1040 becomes their FAFSA. The rest of it can be handled by data matching. Parents could do it in the student’s junior year in high school to get an estimate for the upcoming year.

Obviously, there would be people who will want to report changes in circumstances so we would need a form to collect that type of information from them. These folks would be the exceptions to the rule. The numbers would be much smaller than for all of the current fafsa filers.

Added benefit, In addition to an increase in applications for truly poor folks, congress and the department of education would be more directly involved in the verification and data discrepancy business. They might actually have to deal with all the rich folk cheats who get away with murder every year.

I applaude any effort to increase college attendance among the poor.

Robert Foultz, Assistant Director of Financial Aid at West Chester University, at 8:51 am EDT on March 22, 2007

Mr. Foultz’s Skewed View of the World

Mr. Foultz writes of “. . .the rich folk cheats who get away with murder every year.” Yes, I can picture them right now, huddled ’round the fireplace at the men’s grill in the country club, scheming to save a couple thousand off the sticker price at West Chester University. Puuuuuhhhhlease! Some “rich folk” probably helped to start your school, certainly help to keep it funded, and no doubt will always be part of its ongoing success. Playing the class warfare card is just plain silly.

Jim, at 9:51 am EDT on March 22, 2007

Mr. Foultz’s Accurate View of the World

What Mr. Foultz says about entirely non-needy people getting more than their share of financial aid is entirely true, I have seen countless examples in 20+ years of aid administration. Thanks largely to tax loopholes that can only benefit the wealthy, I have seen many families who can (or at least try to) manuever, manipulate and play the system to make it appear as though they have much less money than they really do have. An entire cottage industry of “financial aid consultants” has grown out of the interest in the upper class as to how they can get their hands on money intended for people in very different circumstances. Legal, unfortunately, but the moral equivalent of working under the table while collecting unemployment.

But about the FAFSA simplification itself, I applaud it but the potential problem here is its limitation to only providing information about Federal aid, which at many schools is only a small piece of the entire aid package. Many families may see that they qualify for x amount of Pell and a $2625 loan, no information about Campus-based aid, state aid or institutional aid because the Dept of Ed can’t make those decisions. I fear that the result is that they won’t understand that there are missing pieces, and they’ll think that they won’t be able to afford it because they’ll have such limited information.

DS, at 1:36 pm EDT on March 22, 2007

FAFSA Simplified

Family Contribution calculators have been available on line for several years. This is nothing new. What is and will be confusing is the “Estimated Family Contribution". The Federal Department of Education, by using this terminology, gives parents the impression that the EFC is the only amount of money they will need to pay for college costs. This is not true. A Federal Pell Grant can’t cover the costs of tuition, fees, room and board at most state universities. Furthermore, families with incomes under 40,000 are not even qualifying for the Pell Grant. Many colleges provide more scholarship and grant funds to students than the Federal Government does. With the neediest of students, few school can afford to meet full financial need. An EFC of zero gives the impress that all costs will be taken care of since “FAFSA says I can’t contribute anything to school, so why do I owe you money.” Let’s go back to a more appropriate term “Student Aid Index", which reflects the indexing of aid eligibility.

Pat Watkins, Director of Financial Aid, at 2:45 pm EDT on March 22, 2007

I agree with both DS and Pat. Much more must be done to fully inform.

My previous comments were more narrowly addressing the problem of too many low income folks who just never get to the fafsa.

Since I prepare taxes on the side, I see lots of misconception, error and avoidance. Tieing the two together (tax and fafsa) might have the effect of getting more low income folks to file taxes as well. Many low income tax filers simply miss out on some of the tax benefits available to them.

Robert Foultz, at 9:05 pm EDT on March 22, 2007

I think that it is well past the time for some changes to the FAFSA form. One of the main problems that students have with the form is collecting their parents financial information. Some, because the parents refuse to give the info, and others, because parents haven’t filed their returns yet. How will these problems be addressed? We must also have a way of letting students and parents know that they are responsible for contacting the Financial Aid ofice at their school to inquire about other paperwork needed to award other types of aid. Overall, the idea of a simplified FAFSA process is great and it can’t come too soon.

Debra Payton, FA Specialist at Laney Community College, at 2:31 pm EDT on March 26, 2007

Advertisement

 Jobs Related to 'First Step' on Simplifying Aid Form

or search for jobs directly.

Senior Research Associate — Position # 139601
Miami Dade College

Job Description: The Senior Research Associate conducts quantitative and qualitative research projects and produces routine ... see job

Program Manager-Child Psychiatry Program
University of Colorado at Denver and Health Sciences Center-Downtown Denver

Posting Description: The University of Colorado Denver’s Anschutz Medical Campus is a a world-class, ... see job

Grid and Application Programmer
Cornell University

Cornell University, located in Ithaca, New York, is an inclusive, dynamic, and innovative Ivy League university and New ... see job

Assistant Professor of Political Science — International Relations
Roger Williams University

Roger Williams University is one of the top ranked liberal arts universities in the Northeast and is an Equal Opportunity ... see job

Test Preparation Noncredit Adjunct Faculty Pool
Howard Community College

Howard Community College is building a pool of applicants for adjunct faculty positions in Continuing Education in the area ... see job

Temporary Lecturer, Department of Physics & Astronomy
University of California, Irvine

The Department of Physics and Astronomy anticipates temporary openings for Lecturers. These positions usually become ... see job

Assistant Professor, Early Childhood Education
College of the Bahamas

DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES Candidate should have a Ph.D. or EdD. in Early Childhood Education with a minimum of 3 years of ... see job

Secretary, Administrative — 4076W
Saint Louis University

Saint Louis University is a Jesuit Catholic University. Through teaching, research, health care and community service, Saint ... see job

Assistant VP for Strategic Development
University of Texas, San Antonio

Description of Job Duties: Provide leadership in strategic expansion of UTSA research Develop new & expanded ... see job

Physical Education
Keene State College

We are Creating a World of Possibilities! see job