News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Jan. 26, 2006
Where’s Sputnik when you need it?
“This is not a Sputnik we are faced with,” said Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-NM), referring to the reason there has been a lack of urgency about promoting science and math education in America. “Rather, it’s a series of trends that are against us.”
Bingaman and three other senators said Wednesday that they are feeling urgency as they introduced the PACE (Protecting America’s Competitive Edge) Act.
Faced with a flat world – the salary of one engineer in the United States will get you 11 in India – and alarming educational statistics – as of 1999, 41 percent of U.S. 8th graders, as opposed to 71 percent internationally, received instruction from a teacher specializing in math – the act is a three bill package that authorizes $8.95 billion in the first year, and more each year through 2013, to bring America up to speed. Separate appropriations bills would have to provide the actual funds.
Some details, most importantly procuring the billions, are not yet worked out, but experts lauded the initiative as a strong, bipartisan and much needed message. The act embraces 20 recommendations – some focused on higher education – made in the “Rising Above the Gathering Storm” report issued by the National Academies.
For higher education, the act asks for 30,000 merit-based scholarships yearly; 25,000 scholarships – up to $20,000 per year – for high school graduates studying science, engineering, or math, and 5,000 research fellowships for graduate students that would cover education costs and provide a stipend.
One of the problems “Gathering Storm” identified was the lack of well-trained science and math teachers to groom a generation of students. To that end, the bill also calls for the creation of 10,000 competitive scholarships – up to $20,000 a year – each year for undergraduate students studying math or science who agree to concurrently work on their teacher certification and to teach for at least four years after graduation.
Nils Hasselmo, president of the Association of American Universities, said that, though details need to be worked out, “we are very pleased that there is political traction for the idea. Nineteen senators, 10 Republicans and 9 Democrats, have agreed to co-sponsor the bill, and Sen. Pete Domenici (R-NM), one of those who introduced the bill, said President Bush may mention it in his State of the Union Address next week.
Paying for the bill is of course the challenge. “There are resource issues, but the fact this is being placed so strongly is important,” Hasselmo said. Added Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN), one of the senators introducing the act: “If we only spend money on war … hurricanes, welfare, debt … we will lose our standard of living.” The fact that Senators Domenici and Mikulski are on the Senate Appropriations Committee could help the effort.
If the bill moves forward as is, universities should indirectly benefit from an outlined 10 percent increase per year over seven years in spending caps for basic research budgets in key federal agencies.
The bill also says that colleges should get grants in the interest of promoting “summer academies,” one-to-two week crash courses for science and math teachers that would seek to push them farther toward the cutting edge.
Kathy Norman, professor of science education at the California State University at San Marcos, and president of the Association for Science Teacher Education, said that resources are scarce when it comes to educating and recruiting top science teachers. In terms of math and science education, “we are in very serious trouble in this country, k-to-college,” Norman said. She commended the push to identify potential science teachers when they are undergraduate science students, and added that she hopes the merit scholarships will “pay attention to attracting people from diverse backgrounds.”
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
First, it will take a long time if we are to improve the science and math skills of our students. Standards are low, textbooks are poorly written and the best and brightest do not go into teaching because of the salaries and the working conditions. There is no support for being tough, no support for high expectations and the cultural messages are horrible, namely that total success can be achieved with some combination of attitude, fashion, and street smarts (want to be a math major now?).
Second, the U.S. is not doing too badly importing foreign talent. International students in a lot of countries understand that education in science, engineering, and mathematics is the road up and are not afraid to put in years of study to that end. We are educating many of these students in our research universities and one assumes (hopes?) they will find employment in our domestic technology companies and work hare and innovate on our behalf. That is the only way we will stay above water in technical fields. Of course these “domestic” technology companies are now discovering that if they maintain R&D facilities off shore, they can attract the same talent at much lower cost. What this means for our future, and whether we can sustain our leading position in technology through the importation of talent, I do not know. I do know that our own educational system (except perhaps in certain sectors of higher education) and our own students are not doing the job.
Bob, at 3:35 pm EST on January 26, 2006
my daughter is a freshman in college & wants to be a high school biology teacher. She didnt get any extra money for majoring in science.
how is one supposed to apply for the scholarships?
julie, at 8:41 am EST on January 31, 2006
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
FGCU, a member of the State University System of Florida, is a comprehensive university created to address the educational ... see job
Gordon College Department of Economics and Business Position Announcement Microeconomics The Department of Economics and ... see job
Angelo State University is an equal opportunity employer and seeks to build a diverse workforce community. see job
Posting Description: ANP/NP/PA to provide primary care services in an academic group practice Internal ... see job
CalIT2 California Institute for Telecommunications and Information Technology Position: Project Scientists Salary: ... see job
Job Description: Coaching
Duties of Position:
Education ... see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
Current projects in the Vitamin K program include: determination of dietary vitamin K requirements in older adults; use ... see job
American University is an independent liberal-arts university located in Washington, DC with 12,000 students. The faculty are ... see job
Job Summary: University College, School of Professional and Continuing Studies, is currently ... see job
Too Little, Too Late
Today’s senators don’t have a clue, do they? Remember the day when politicians had to hide the fact they possessed a doctorate? Now the public elect politicians who are overtly proud of, boast about, their ignorance and insularity, neither of which stems the tide of their arrogance.
Ezra Gilgh, at 9:11 am EST on January 26, 2006