News, Views and Careers for All of Higher Education
Jan. 19, 2007
How do you construct a narrative about college freshmen these days? Researchers at the University of California at Los Angeles take their shot annually with a survey of 270,000 entering undergraduates at roughly 400 colleges across the country.
This year’s data show that the first-year students are increasingly politically minded and moving away from the center of the political spectrum. They are far apart on many social issues and appear mixed on affirmative action. They are concerned about financing their educations and are fully confident in their academic abilities.
One in three students reported discussing politics frequently during their last year of high school, according to “The American Freshman: National Norms for Fall 2006,” (a brief summary is available) a product of UCLA’s Cooperative Institutional Research Program. That’s up from 26 percent in 2004, the last time that question was asked, and represents the highest total in the 40 years of the survey.
“This bodes well for fostering democratic citizenship during college,” Sylvia Hurtado, director of the Higher Education Research Institute, which administered the survey, said in a statement.
The findings are, perhaps, not surprising, given that many expect the 18- to 24-year-old turnout from last fall’s midterm elections to break records once the data are revealed. A report from Harvard University’s Institute of Politics, released before the elections, foreshadowed increasing political activity. In that poll, 32 percent of people in the college-going age category said they “definitely will be voting,” and three in four said the likelihood that they would cast ballots was at least 50 percent.
John H. Pryor, director of the Cooperative Institutional Research Program, said it’s not just a matter of students being hyped up during an even-numbered election year. “There’s an assumption people have been making about how these numbers jump up or down based on the circumstances, but this year’s numbers [of students saying they talked politics] was higher than in past presidential election years.”
If the data improve the prospects for democratic dialogue on campuses, as Hurtado suggests, they also portend more conflict. The proportion of students who identified themselves as being liberal (28 percent) and conservative (24 percent) were the highest in decades. Fewer than half said they are “middle of the road” — the lowest percentage measured since 1970.
“We try to make this useful for colleges, and the piece about political affiliations gives them a heads-up that a trend is coming through,” Pryor said. “You can assume that there are going to be heated arguments on campus that will need to be examined.”
Students in the survey were also asked about their views on a range of social issues. The one that most divides the self-identified liberals and conservatives: same-sex marriage. Eighty-four percent of liberals said same-sex couples should have the right to legal marital status, compared with 30 percent of conservatives who share that view.
Slightly more than 50 percent of conservative students agree that affirmative action in college admissions should be abolished, while just under 50 percent of liberal students take that stance. The survey didn’t break down the data by ethnic or racial groups.
Two of three students surveyed said they have “some” or “major” concerns about paying for college. For those who were admitted to their first-choice college but who didn’t attend, the inability to afford tuition at the institution was a primarily reason to enroll elsewhere, according to the report.
The survey also measures who is taking advanced placement courses in high school. In all, an increasing number of students are taking at least one AP course during their senior year. Asian students led in this category, ahead of white students. Fewer than half of black students took one or more AP course as seniors — the lowest of any racial or ethnic group. The report found that black students are the most likely to attend high schools that don’t offer the courses.
Making more money and getting a better job were two of the top reasons that students cited for choosing to go to college. And Lake Wobegon lives: Seventy-two percent of men and 66 percent of women surveyed said they are either “above average” or in the “highest 10 percent” of academic ability.
Want it on paper? Print this page.
Know someone who’d be interested? Forward this story.
Want to stay informed? Sign up for free daily news e-mail.
Advertisement
The actual data from the study show 23.9 percent call themselves conservative, and 28.4 percent call themselves liberal. The rounding off of these numbers in the above article (one rounded up, the other down) shaves a half a percentage point off the total discrepancy, which may not sound like much—except that it could be rounded up to a full number! Why not?
By the way, in terms of the study, when will the poll-takers get it through their noggins that it’s possible not to accept either “conservative” or “liberal” as a designation? Why not “right of center” or “left of center"? Do political philosophies only come in two flavors? In what world? Scholars, of all people, ought to realize that there has been a sustained criticism of liberalism from the left, and that there are plenty on the right who don’t define themselves as conservative. Why should we accept the banal political categories of network television?
Christopher Phelps, Department of History at The Ohio State University, at 7:45 am EST on January 19, 2007
Well said, Mr. Phelps. This “either/or” labeling is a logical fallacy that produces inaccurate images of and further rifts between higher education constituents.
kgotthardt, at 9:55 am EST on January 19, 2007
“ .. When will the poll-takers get it through their noggins that it’s possible not to accept either “conservative” or “liberal” ..”
Perhaps they are waiting for you to show them how? They’re only at UCLA, and have been doing the survey for several years. Have mercy, please.
C. Bigsby, at 12:10 pm EST on January 19, 2007
Well, one is rounded up and the other down because that is how the math works. If the difference between “conservative” and “liberal” were to be expressed, then it would be proper to round it up to 5%, but, as the respective totals were used, it is just as proper to round the “conservative” percentage up and the “liberal” percentage down. There may be things to critique about this article, but I hardly think that is one of them.
David Johnson, Case Western Reserve University, at 12:15 pm EST on January 19, 2007
What I don’t understand is what “liberal” or “conservative” actually means. There is a plethora of issues in this country within the realm of education. There are many,many issues outside of education. I would consider myself “right of center” on some issues and “left of center” on others. On what percentage of issues must you be “left of center” or “right of center” to qualify as a liberal or conservative? Who gets to make that decision? Why do we feel compelled to have a label for everything?
Ray Miller, at 1:05 pm EST on January 19, 2007
I find it interesting that the numbers on affirmative action were so close- that so many “liberals” were against it and so many “conservatives” were for it.
I’m very concerned about the reality check students need regarding their preparedness and academic ability. This isn’t just their problem though- high school teachers and administrators also seem to think they are adequately preparing their students for college, whereas college instructors find the case to be substantially otherwise.
Marc Healy, at 1:05 pm EST on January 19, 2007
Re this:"Making more money and getting a better job were two of the top reasons that students cited for choosing to go to college. And Lake Wobegon lives: Seventy-two percent of men and 66 percent of women surveyed said they are either “above average” or in the “highest 10 percent” of academic ability.”
Just a thought, at 2:35 pm EST on January 19, 2007
Between Liberals and Conservatives, where do Progressives fit in? Some “progressive” ideas are downright conservative, by old standards, and not all “liberals” are progressive.
TM, AIMC Berkeley, at 10:20 pm EST on January 19, 2007
Phelps, I’d recommend that you take a look at the actual instrument used in the Cooperative Institutional Research Program (http://www.gseis.ucla.edu/heri/freshman.html). You’ll find that students have a choice to respond: Far left, Liberal, Middle of the Road, Conservative and Far Right. I believe that when the freshmen norms are released, HERI counts Far Left and Liberal together and do the same with Conservative and Far Right. In addition, students answer questions on issues that further define typically liberal or conservative viewpoints (such as gun control, abortion, affirmative action and role of women).
cindylu, response to christopher phelps at ucla, at 8:45 am EST on January 20, 2007
Cindylu is right. We’ve used the CIRP since 1994, and when working with the data (particuarly at an evangelical institution like ours) it’s important to distinguish between students’ self-identification as “conservative,” or “middle of the road” and how they actually think about a range of social and political issues. Students ten years ago habitually described themselves as conservative; more are now likely to describe themselves as middle of the road. But their attitudes on social issues usually associated with those positions in the popular mind haven’t changed very much.We also talk at my institution about students arriving with “parent faith,” that is, that their faith commitments are often those of their parents, and unexamined—the same is true of their politics.
Rich Sherry, Dean, at 8:30 am EST on January 21, 2007
I don’t know what goes on in other parts of the country, but in Western Massachusetts every middle school and high school honor roll routinely awards honors and high honors to some 35-50% of each class. “Back in the good ol’ days", only the top 5 percent of the class was recognized as excellent and the next 10 percent was noted to be above average in order to sport a silver cord with one’s graduation gown. I think we need to look at our collective Lake Wobegon glasses [read: schools responsible for grade inflation] which tends to see an overabundance of our young ones as “above average". How do colleges differentiate between all those high achievers??
Marybeth Mitts, Asst. Dir of Corporate and Foundation Relations at Williams College, at 12:00 pm EST on January 22, 2007
It’s great to know that the study had more refined categories than “liberal” and “conservative,” but my basic point remains the same. It’s unclear to me whether IHE’s reporting or the study’s press release is to blame, but the above article did not give anything but the broadest-brush generalizations. Perhaps next year IHE could go beyond “liberal” and “conservative” as classifications to give breakdowns on specific issues polled and report those who classified themselves far left and far right, rather than lumping them in with liberals or conservatives?
As for the math lesson, gee thanks, I kind of knew that rounding up and down was the way to do it. The point was that in so rounding them off—which the study data did not do—the reporting truncated the gap between left and right indicated in student opinion by a half a percentage point, a significant amount.
Christopher Phelps, Department of History at The Ohio State University, at 9:17 am EST on January 24, 2007
But the article’s point was not to highlight the discrepancy between the number of students who identified as liberal or conservative; rather, it simply said that more students reported themselves as being on one side or the other. Their point was polarization in its own right. Their rounded numbers add to 52, the exact numbers to 52.3...for what they are trying to communicate, the rounding is more than appropriate.
David Johnson, Case Western Reserve University, at 4:36 pm EST on January 29, 2007
Advertisement
or search for jobs directly.
For more information and application please visit our website http://www.losrios.edu and ... see job
The Department of Special Education invites applications for three (3) tenure-track Assistant Professors in the Department of ... see job
Posting Description: Open Competitive Position Examination IT TECHNICIAN I H2I1IN Posting # 805704 for ... see job
Located 10 miles west of Chicago in the suburb of River Forest, is a Christian liberal arts institution. It is a member ... see job
St. Mary’s University invites applications for two deanships: Dean of Business and Dean of Science, Engineering and ... see job
East Carolina University, a constituent institution of the University of North Carolina, is a doctoral institution with an ... see job
The University of Minnesota is a premier employer and a talent magnet attracting leading faculty and staff from around the ... see job
Loyola’s office of Marketing and Communications has an opening for a Web Content Manager. This position provides strategic ... see job
Posting Description: The Department of Classics at the University of Colorado invites applications for a ... see job
Engineering Services see job
SAT & ACT, thank you
” .. they are either “above average” or in the “highest 10 percent” of academic ability ..”
As to the latter — it would be interesting to compare that statement to overall SAT scores. Those on the front lines of higher-ed often see a serious gap between statements and reality.
C. Bigsby, at 6:26 am EST on January 19, 2007